How can I help?

brightplace uses ai, verify answers

Sugar Run at New Albany

Sugar Run at New Albany 1 of 1

$1,291 – $2,534/mo

  • 1–3 bedrooms
  • 1–2 baths
  • 704–1,388 sq ft
  • 32 units available
  • Pet friendly
5501 New Albany Rd E, New Albany, OH, 43054

As of November 20, 2026, Sugar Run at New Albany in New Albany, OH has 32 apartments for rent from $1,291 to $2,534/mo. One-bedrooms start at $1,291, two-bedrooms at $1,465, and three-bedrooms at $2,534.


At a glance

Price vs. nearby

3% below

Similar apartments, by size
  • 32 apartments available

    1 bd 15 · 2 bd 16 · 3 bd 1

  • 8 ready to move in now

    More open up from Nov 26


Floor plans

Sugar Run at New Albany has 32 units available across 12 floor plans: 6 one-bedroom layouts (704–965 sq ft), 5 two-bedroom layouts (971–1,160 sq ft), and a three-bedroom layout (1,388 sq ft). Prices checked November 20, 2026.

The Eastham

1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • 704 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,291/mo

1 available unitPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailableActions
5607$1,291
Just listed
Just listed704Dec 5
View Unit
View Unit

The Eastham with Study

1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • 787 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,386/mo

1 available unitPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailableActions
7078$1,386
Just listed
Just listed787Jan 9
View Unit
View Unit

The Vineyard - Carriage House

1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • 888 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,386/mo

1 available unitPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailableActions
7018$1,386
Just listed
Just listed888Jan 27
View Unit
View Unit

The Eastham with Study Renovated

1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • 787 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,450/mo

7 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailableActions
5619$1,450
Just listed
Just listed787Nov 19
View Unit
View Unit
7031$1,450
Just listed
Just listed787Nov 19
View Unit
View Unit
7114$1,454
Just listed
Just listed787Nov 19
View Unit
View Unit
5676$1,459
Just listed
Just listed787Nov 19
View Unit
View Unit
5591$1,536
Just listed
Just listed787Dec 2
View Unit
View Unit
7076$1,531
Just listed
Just listed787Dec 17
View Unit
View Unit
7164$1,531
Just listed
Just listed787Feb 11
View Unit
View Unit

The Eastham Renovated

1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • 704 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,460/mo

2 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailable
7074$1,460
Just listed
Just listed704Nov 20
5583$1,481
Just listed
Just listed704Dec 25

The Vinyard - Carriage House Renovated

1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • 888 – 965 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,497/mo

3 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailable
7261$1,576
Just listed
Just listed888Nov 26
5523$1,497
Just listed
Just listed965Jan 1
7425$1,551
Just listed
Just listed965Jan 20

The Tisbury

2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 971 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,465/mo

2 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailable
7210$1,515
Just listed
Just listed971Jan 13
7346$1,465
Just listed
Just listed971Jan 16

The Tisbury with Study

2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,057 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,525/mo

2 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailable
7254$1,525
Just listed
Just listed1,057Feb 11
7058$1,525
Just listed
Just listed1,057Feb 20

The Tisbury Renovated

2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 971 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,610/mo

4 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailable
7340$1,735
Just listed
Just listed971Nov 19
7372$1,610
Just listed
Just listed971Nov 28
7368$1,720
Just listed
Just listed971Dec 9
7242$1,755
Just listed
Just listed971Jan 21

The Georgetown - Carriage House

2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,160 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,725/mo

1 available unitPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailable
7423$1,725
Just listed
Just listed1,160Dec 2

The Sagamore Renovated

2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,031 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,780/mo

7 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailable
7404$1,815
Just listed
Just listed1,031Nov 19
5684$1,790
Just listed
Just listed1,031Dec 9
7336$1,785
Just listed
Just listed1,031Dec 10
7024$1,815
Just listed
Just listed1,031Jan 1
7160$1,780
Just listed
Just listed1,031Feb 6
5551$1,810
Just listed
Just listed1,031Feb 11
5560$1,785
Just listed
Just listed1,031Feb 25

The Ratama - Carriage House Renovated

3 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,388 Sq Ft

Starting at $2,534/mo

1 available unitPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailable
5510$2,534
Just listed
Just listed1,388Nov 19

Estimated cost to rent here

At Sugar Run at New Albany, a one-bedroom starts at about $1,548 a month all-in: $1,291 rent and an estimated $257 for electric, gas, water, internet, and renters insurance. A two-bedroom starts at about $1,794 and a three-bedroom at about $2,958.

1 bedroom
2 bedrooms
3 bedrooms

All-in from$1,548/mo

Estimates are local averages, not quotes from the property.

Can you afford it?

Most property managers ask for a monthly income of about 3× the rent, so qualifying at Sugar Run at New Albany takes about $46,476 a year for a one-bedroom, $52,740 for a two-bedroom, and $91,224 for a three-bedroom. Keeping the $1,548 all-in month for a one-bedroom within 35% of take-home pay takes an income of about $64,700 a year.

1 bedroom
2 bedrooms
3 bedrooms

Total monthly housing cost

$1,548/mo

Income to afford it comfortably

$64,700/yr

Income to qualify

$46,476/yr

Your estimated budget

Suggested rent budget, 1 bedroom

$ —/mo

See what you can afford here

Add your income and debts for a rent budget at this building.

Free with a brightplace account

Fees & lease terms

At Sugar Run at New Albany, the security deposit is $300.

  • Rent

    $1,291 – $2,534/mo
  • Security deposit

    $300
  • Earliest move-in

    Jan 1

Amenities

Sugar Run at New Albany is pet friendly and has garage or covered parking and in-unit washers and dryers. It lists 25 amenities, including 24-hour fitness center, heated swimming pool, and private patio or balcony.

  • 24/7 Emergency Maintenance

  • 24-Hour Fitness Center

  • Car Wash Station

  • Community Garden

  • Courtyard With Entertainment Space, Gas Grills, & Glass Firepit

  • Detached Garages Available

  • Disc Golf Course

  • Dog Park

  • Heated Swimming Pool

  • Monthly Resident Events

  • Picnic Pavilion With Grilling Stations, Green Space, Yard Games, & Wood Burning Firepit

  • Resident Lounge With Full Kitchen, Workstations, & Fireplace

  • Starbucks Coffee Station

  • 9ft Ceilings

  • Abundance Of Natural Light

  • Crown Molding

  • Dining Room

  • Granite Countertops

  • Kitchen With Bar Seating And Pantry

  • Private Patio Or Balcony

  • Soaking Tubs

  • Stainless Steel Appliance Package

  • Walk-In Closets

  • Washer And Dryer

  • Wood-Style Plank Flooring


Location

5501 New Albany Rd E, New Albany, OH, 43054


Resident reviews

Sugar Run at New Albany has a 4.2 out of 5 rating from more than 100 resident reviews. Residents rate location (4.8) and amenities and shared spaces (4.2) highest and building quality (1.5) lowest.

4.2 · 100+ reviews
Overall rating
Positive
Mixed
Neutral
Negative
Management4.0
Maintenance3.8
Amenities and Shared Spaces4.2
Location4.8
Building Quality1.5
Overall100 reviews

Sugar Run offers spacious, well-maintained units with attractive amenities including a renovated gym, clubhouse, pool, and community events. Leasing and maintenance staff are consistently praised for responsiveness and professionalism. However, recurring concerns include trash compactor breakdowns and overflow, late fees for payment delays without exception policies, rising rent and utility costs, and occasional maintenance issues like water leaks and window problems.

Management and office staff receive consistently positive feedback for responsiveness, friendliness, and helpfulness, particularly during leasing and move-in processes. However, significant concerns persist regarding communication responsiveness to billing and maintenance issues, trash compactor maintenance and overflow, and follow-through on maintenance repairs. Residents report inconsistent experiences, with some praising staff availability while others describe delayed responses and unresolved issues.

Maintenance response times are generally prompt, with many residents reporting same-day or next-day service for urgent issues like HVAC failures. However, recurring problems with water leaks, incomplete repairs requiring multiple visits, and unresolved maintenance items (such as non-functional windows and misaligned doors) create frustration for some residents. Quality of repairs varies, with some residents praising technician professionalism while others report inadequate solutions and follow-up gaps.

Residents consistently praise the property's amenities, including a well-maintained gym, clubhouse, pool, and community garden. Grounds and common areas are generally kept clean, with recent renovations noted positively. However, recurring concerns include trash and recycling management issues, occasional maintenance delays, and parking/vehicle security concerns that some residents have experienced.

Residents consistently praise the property's location near businesses and downtown amenities, with convenient walkability to nearby stores and services. The neighborhood is described as safe and peaceful, with a pleasant community environment. Common amenities including the gym, clubhouse, and pool are well-maintained and appreciated by residents.

Residents report significant building maintenance issues, including recurring water leaks and incomplete repairs such as holes left unfixed for extended periods. Mold has been painted over rather than properly remediated, and water damage to drywall and baseboards has occurred multiple times. These unresolved maintenance concerns have resulted in property damage requiring costly repairs.

Summaries are written by AI from reviews residents posted on public review sites. Each topic shows how many of those reviews discuss it.

Getting around

Sugar Run at New Albany is car-dependent and not bikeable, and transit is minimal.

Walking
Car-dependent
Grade F
Transit
Minimal
Grade F
Biking
Not bikeable
Grade F

About this property

Discover current pricing for Sugar Run apartments in New Albany, OH, including 1, 2 & 3-bedroom floor plans designed for comfort.


Nearby schools

The closest school to Sugar Run at New Albany is New Albany KinderCare, a private preschool less than 0.1 miles away. The closest public school is New Albany Early Learning Center, 0.5 miles away.

SchoolTypeLevelDistance

New Albany KinderCare

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.1 mi

The Goddard School - New Albany

Private · Elementary
PrivateElementary0.3 mi

Ready Set Grow Preschool of New Albany

Private · Elementary
PrivateElementary0.5 mi

New Albany Early Learning Center

Public · Elementary
PublicElementary0.5 mi

New Albany Intermediate School

Public · Elementary
PublicElementary0.8 mi

New Albany High School

Public · High
PublicHigh0.8 mi

New Albany Middle School

Public · Middle
PublicMiddle0.9 mi

New Albany Primary School

Public · Elementary
PublicElementary0.9 mi

New Albany Montessori School

Private · Elementary
PrivateElementary0.9 mi

Today's Child Montessori School

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool1.0 mi

Similar properties

The closest matches in New Albany, OH.


Rent history

Over the past 30 days, the average asking rent at Sugar Run at New Albany has held at $1,617. The current average is $1,617.

Prices reflect the average advertised rent across units listed as available each day (1 day observed).

How fast apartments rent

In the last 4 weeks, 0 came off the market and 0 were newly listed.

—

typical time listed

0

came off the market in 4 weeks

0

new listings in 4 weeks

Week of Aug 31: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Sep 7: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Sep 14: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Sep 21: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Sep 28: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Oct 5: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Oct 12: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Oct 19: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Oct 26: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Nov 2: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Nov 9: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Nov 16: 0 listed, 0 off the marketAug 31Week of Nov 16
Newly listed
Came off the market
From nightly checks of the building's website since Nov 19. An apartment that came off the market may have rented or been taken off by the building.

Contact & management

Sugar Run at New Albany is managed by Coastal Ridge Real Estate. The leasing office's phone number is (614) 775-0100.