How can I help?

brightplace uses ai, verify answers

Cortland at New Albany

Cortland at New Albany – Kitchen
1 / 4

$1,865 – $2,567/mo

  • 2 bedrooms
  • 1–2.5 baths
  • 924–1,754 sq ft
  • 35 units available
  • Pet friendly
5185 Sulgrave Dr, New Albany, OH, 43054

As of November 20, 2026, Cortland at New Albany in New Albany, OH has 35 apartments for rent from $1,865 to $2,567/mo. The average asking rent has risen 19.7% since April 14, 2026, from $1,849 to $2,213.


At a glance

Prices lately

Steady

Listed apartments, last 30 days

Price vs. nearby

13% below

Similar apartments, by size
  • 35 apartments available

    2 bd 35

  • 16 ready to move in now

    More open up from Nov 27

  • Rents in about 1 day

    Typical time an apartment stays listed


Floor plans

Cortland at New Albany has 35 units available across 3 floor plans: 3 two-bedroom layouts (924–1,754 sq ft). Prices checked November 20, 2026.

Milburne

2 Bedrooms • 2.5 Baths • 1,402 Sq Ft

Starting at $2,112/mo

23 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailableActions
7226H$2,112
Just listed
Just listed1,402Oct 17
View Unit
View Unit
7226H$2,112
Just listed
Just listed1,402Oct 17
View Unit
View Unit
7226H$2,112
Just listed
Just listed1,402Oct 17
View Unit
View Unit
7226H$2,112
Just listed
Just listed1,402Oct 17
View Unit
View Unit
7293T$2,167
Just listed
Just listed1,402Nov 27
View Unit
View Unit
7293T$2,167
Just listed
Just listed1,402Nov 27
View Unit
View Unit
5242SH$2,217
Just listed
Just listed1,402Nov 27
View Unit
View Unit
5242SH$2,217
Just listed
Just listed1,402Nov 27
View Unit
View Unit
5242SH$2,217
Just listed
Just listed1,402Dec 8
View Unit
View Unit
5242SH$2,217
Just listed
Just listed1,402Dec 8
View Unit
View Unit
7269T$2,167
Just listed
Just listed1,402Jan 11
View Unit
View Unit
7269T$2,167
Just listed
Just listed1,402Jan 11
View Unit
View Unit
7269T$2,167
Just listed
Just listed1,402Jan 11
View Unit
View Unit
7269T$2,167
Just listed
Just listed1,402Jan 11
View Unit
View Unit
7299H$2,167
Just listed
Just listed1,402Jan 12
View Unit
View Unit
7299H$2,167
Just listed
Just listed1,402Jan 12
View Unit
View Unit
7299H$2,167
Just listed
Just listed1,402Jan 12
View Unit
View Unit
7275H$2,167
Just listed
Just listed1,402Jan 27
View Unit
View Unit
7275H$2,167
Just listed
Just listed1,402Jan 27
View Unit
View Unit
5172S$2,192
Just listed
Just listed1,402Feb 15
View Unit
View Unit
5172S$2,192
Just listed
Just listed1,402Feb 15
View Unit
View Unit
5172S$2,192
Just listed
Just listed1,402Feb 15
View Unit
View Unit
5172S$2,192
Just listed
Just listed1,402Feb 15
View Unit
View Unit

Warwick

2 Bedrooms • 2.5 Baths • 1,754 Sq Ft

Starting at $2,512/mo

8 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailableActions
7237H$2,512
Just listed
Just listed1,754Oct 9
View Unit
View Unit
7237H$2,512
Just listed
Just listed1,754Oct 9
View Unit
View Unit
7237H$2,512
Just listed
Just listed1,754Oct 9
View Unit
View Unit
7237H$2,512
Just listed
Just listed1,754Oct 9
View Unit
View Unit
7253H$2,567
Just listed
Just listed1,754Oct 28
View Unit
View Unit
7253H$2,567
Just listed
Just listed1,754Oct 28
View Unit
View Unit
7253H$2,567
Just listed
Just listed1,754Oct 28
View Unit
View Unit
7253H$2,567
Just listed
Just listed1,754Oct 28
View Unit
View Unit

Estimated cost to rent here

At Cortland at New Albany, a two-bedroom starts at about $2,194 a month all-in: $1,865 rent and an estimated $329 for electric, gas, water, internet, and renters insurance.

2 bedrooms

All-in from$2,194/mo

Estimates are local averages, not quotes from the property.

Can you afford it?

Most property managers ask for a monthly income of about 3× the rent, so qualifying at Cortland at New Albany takes about $67,140 a year for a two-bedroom. Keeping the $2,194 all-in month for a two-bedroom within 35% of take-home pay takes an income of about $97,200 a year.

2 bedrooms

Total monthly housing cost

$2,194/mo

Income to afford it comfortably

$97,200/yr

Income to qualify

$67,140/yr

Your estimated budget

Suggested rent budget, 2 bedrooms

$ —/mo

See what you can afford here

Add your income and debts for a rent budget at this building.

Free with a brightplace account

Fees & lease terms

  • Rent

    $1,865 – $2,567/mo
  • Earliest move-in

    Jan 11

Amenities

Cortland at New Albany is pet friendly and has garage or covered parking and in-unit washers and dryers. It lists 34 amenities, including elevate fitness, resort-style pool and sun deck, and personal patios and balconies.

  • 24/7 Fitness Center With Spin Studio

  • Barbecue Grill

  • Cortland Front Door

  • Double Vanities

  • Elevate Fitness

  • Elevate Fitness Experience And Free Group Classes

  • Live Easy Guarantees

  • Modern Lighting

  • Next-Level Apartment Living

  • Nine-Foot Ceilings With Crown Molding

  • Pet-Friendly Apartments

  • Pet-Friendly Cortland Community

  • Pickleball Court

  • Private, Attached Garages

  • Resort-Style Pool And Sun Deck

  • Smoke-Free Cortland Community

  • Smoke-Free Living

  • Townhome-Style Floor Plans

  • Undermount Sinks With Gooseneck Faucets

  • Walkability To Nearby Shops And Dining

  • Zoned To Top-Rated New Albany Schools

  • Cortland Resident Portal And Mobile App

  • Energy-Efficient, Stainless Steel Appliances

  • Gas Fireplaces

  • Granite Countertops

  • In-Home, Full-Size Washer And Dryer Sets

  • Modern Cabinetry With Designer Hardware And Tile Backsplash

  • Personal Patios And Balconies

  • Planned Resident Social Events

  • Resident Clubhouse With Wifi

  • Resident Events

  • Spacious Walk-In Closets

  • Walk-In Showers

  • Wood-Style Flooring


Amenity photos

  • Pool
  • Gym

Location

5185 Sulgrave Dr, New Albany, OH, 43054


Resident reviews

Cortland at New Albany has a 4.2 out of 5 rating from more than 200 resident reviews. Residents rate amenities and shared spaces (5.0) and location (4.4) highest and building quality (1.5) lowest.

4.2 · 200+ reviews
Overall rating
Positive
Mixed
Neutral
Negative
Management4.4
Maintenance4.4
Location4.4
Amenities and Shared Spaces5.0
Building Quality1.5
Overall100 reviews

Cortland New Albany receives overwhelmingly positive feedback, with 88% of reviews rating the property favorably. Residents consistently praise the leasing and office staff for their professionalism, responsiveness, and welcoming approach, as well as the maintenance team for quick and reliable service. The property itself is well-maintained with attractive amenities including a pool, gym, and pickleball court. However, a small number of residents report significant concerns including maintenance delays, building condition issues (water leaks, window drafts, appliance problems), noise from neighbors, and communication gaps during resident disputes.

Management and office staff receive consistent praise for responsiveness, friendliness, and professionalism, with maintenance requests typically completed within 24 hours. However, some residents report communication gaps through the property app, inconsistent enforcement of policies, and concerns about management responsiveness to serious resident issues. Billing disputes and lease term changes have also been noted as sources of frustration.

Maintenance response times are typically fast, with most requests completed within 24 hours and emergency repairs addressed within 90 minutes. Residents consistently report professional and courteous service from maintenance staff. However, some residents report ongoing issues with appliance repairs, water intrusion, and lack of follow-up on persistent problems, with occasional communication gaps regarding service notifications and emergency work.

The property benefits from a convenient location with good freeway access and proximity to shops, restaurants, and coffee venues. However, parking availability is a notable concern, particularly for residents with multiple vehicles, as surface lot parking can be limited and contested during peak times. Most residents appreciate the neighborhood's cleanliness and accessibility, though some note that parking distances and enforcement policies could be improved.

Residents consistently praise the property's amenities, including the pool, gym, and community spaces, along with responsive maintenance and staff support. The community hosts regular events and activities that encourage resident engagement. However, one review notes that the older property requires maintenance attention, including issues with trash compactor overflow and grounds upkeep, as well as parking management and enforcement in high-traffic areas.

Residents report significant building condition issues including water intrusion through windows and garage, deteriorating finishes such as damaged kitchen flooring, and malfunctioning appliances that are repaired rather than replaced. Noise insulation is inadequate, with residents disturbed by neighbor activity through thin walls. Maintenance responsiveness and communication appear inconsistent, with residents noting delayed repairs and lack of advance notice for service interruptions.

Summaries are written by AI from reviews residents posted on public review sites. Each topic shows how many of those reviews discuss it.

Getting around

Cortland at New Albany is somewhat walkable and not bikeable, and transit is minimal.

Walking
Somewhat walkable
Grade D
Transit
Minimal
Grade F
Biking
Not bikeable
Grade F

About this property

Welcome to our New Albany, OH apartments. Discover our one and two-bedroom floor plans at Cortland at New Albany. Schedule a tour today!


Nearby schools

The closest school to Cortland at New Albany is Ready Set Grow Preschool of New Albany, a private elementary school 0.3 miles away. The closest public school is New Albany Early Learning Center, 0.4 miles away.

SchoolTypeLevelDistance

Ready Set Grow Preschool of New Albany

Private · Elementary
PrivateElementary0.3 mi

New Albany Early Learning Center

Public · Elementary
PublicElementary0.4 mi

The Goddard School - New Albany

Private · Elementary
PrivateElementary0.5 mi

New Albany Montessori School

Private · Elementary
PrivateElementary0.7 mi

New Albany High School

Public · High
PublicHigh0.7 mi

Today's Child Montessori School

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.7 mi

New Albany Intermediate School

Public · Elementary
PublicElementary0.7 mi

New Albany KinderCare

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.8 mi

New Albany Middle School

Public · Middle
PublicMiddle0.8 mi

New Albany Primary School

Public · Elementary
PublicElementary0.9 mi

Similar properties

The closest matches in New Albany, OH.


Rent history

Over the past year, the average asking rent at Cortland at New Albany has ranged from $1,829 to $2,418. The current average is $2,213, up $364 (19.7%) from $1,849 at the start.

Prices reflect the average advertised rent across units listed as available each day (204 days observed).

How fast apartments rent

Apartments at Cortland at New Albany typically stay listed about 1 day before coming off the market. In the last 4 weeks, 193 came off the market and 228 were newly listed.

~1 day

typical time listed

193

came off the market in 4 weeks

228

new listings in 4 weeks

Week of Aug 31: 65 listed, 65 off the marketWeek of Sep 7: 63 listed, 63 off the marketWeek of Sep 14: 48 listed, 48 off the marketWeek of Sep 21: 43 listed, 43 off the marketWeek of Sep 28: 49 listed, 49 off the marketWeek of Oct 5: 49 listed, 49 off the marketWeek of Oct 12: 49 listed, 49 off the marketWeek of Oct 19: 49 listed, 49 off the marketWeek of Oct 26: 54 listed, 54 off the marketWeek of Nov 2: 59 listed, 59 off the marketWeek of Nov 9: 59 listed, 59 off the marketWeek of Nov 16: 35 listed, 0 off the marketAug 31Week of Nov 16
Newly listed
Came off the market

Apartments here go quickly. If one fits, it's worth touring soon.

From nightly checks of the building's website since Apr 14. An apartment that came off the market may have rented or been taken off by the building.

Contact & management

Cortland at New Albany is managed by Cortland. The leasing office's phone number is 216-279-0629.