How can I help?

brightplace uses ai, verify answers

The Garratt

The Garratt 1 of 8
1 / 8

$1,485 – $1,950/mo

  • 2–3 bedrooms
  • 2 baths
  • 1,280–1,920 sq ft
  • 24 units available
  • Pet friendly
5415 Turtle Station Way, Westerville, OH, 43081

As of November 20, 2026, The Garratt in Westerville, OH has 24 apartments for rent from $1,485 to $1,950/mo. Two-bedrooms start at $1,485 and three-bedrooms at $1,950. The average asking rent has fallen 11% since May 7, 2026, from $1,868 to $1,662.


At a glance

Prices lately

0.2% higher

Listed apartments, last 30 days

Price vs. nearby

4% below

Similar apartments, by size
  • 24 apartments available

    2 bd 23 · 3 bd 1

  • 5 ready to move in now

    More open up from Nov 21

  • Rents in about 13 days

    Typical time an apartment stays listed


Floor plans

The Garratt has 24 units available across 3 floor plans: 2 two-bedroom layouts (1,280 sq ft) and a three-bedroom layout (1,920 sq ft). Prices checked November 20, 2026.

Charleston

2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,280 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,485/mo

10 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailableActions
CR-5519$1,595
−$20
−$201,280Oct 30
View Unit
View Unit
CR-5464$1,560
−$20
−$201,280Nov 6
View Unit
View Unit
BR-4993$1,645
−$20
−$201,280Nov 14
View Unit
View Unit
CR-5393$1,595
−$20
−$201,280Nov 28
View Unit
View Unit
CR-5401$1,595
−$20
−$201,280Nov 28
View Unit
View Unit
BR-5053$1,645
−$20
−$201,280Nov 28
View Unit
View Unit
CR-5416$1,580
−$20
−$201,280Dec 5
View Unit
View Unit
CR-5489$1,595
−$20
−$201,280Dec 11
View Unit
View Unit
CR-5533$1,485
−$20
−$201,280Dec 19
View Unit
View Unit
CR-5439$1,595
−$20
−$201,280Dec 19
View Unit
View Unit

North Carolina

2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,280 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,595/mo

13 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailableActions
BR-5048$1,780
+$25
+$251,280Oct 31
View Unit
View Unit
BR-5052$1,790
+$25
+$251,280Nov 14
View Unit
View Unit
CR-5363$1,705
+$25
+$251,280Nov 21
View Unit
View Unit
TB-5585$1,695
+$15
+$151,280Nov 27
View Unit
View Unit
TSW-5463$1,800
+$15
+$151,280Nov 27
View Unit
View Unit
TB-5615$1,690
+$25
+$251,280Nov 28
View Unit
View Unit
CR-5389$1,705
+$25
+$251,280Nov 28
View Unit
View Unit
TSW-5483$1,830
+$25
+$251,280Nov 28
View Unit
View Unit
TB-5547$1,730
+$25
+$251,280Dec 2
View Unit
View Unit
BR-5019$1,740
+$25
+$251,280Dec 17
View Unit
View Unit
TSW-5469$1,800
+$15
+$151,280Dec 31
View Unit
View Unit
TSW-5519$1,725
+$25
+$251,280Jan 6
View Unit
View Unit
TB-5562$1,595
+$15
+$151,280Jan 25
View Unit
View Unit

South Carolina

3 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,920 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,950/mo

1 available unitPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailableActions
TB-5553$1,950
+$52
+$521,920Feb 13
View Unit
View Unit

Estimated cost to rent here

At The Garratt, a two-bedroom starts at about $1,814 a month all-in: $1,485 rent and an estimated $329 for electric, gas, water, internet, and renters insurance. A three-bedroom starts at about $2,374.

2 bedrooms
3 bedrooms

All-in from$1,814/mo

Estimates are local averages, not quotes from the property.

Can you afford it?

Most property managers ask for a monthly income of about 3× the rent, so qualifying at The Garratt takes about $53,460 a year for a two-bedroom and $70,200 for a three-bedroom. Keeping the $1,814 all-in month for a two-bedroom within 35% of take-home pay takes an income of about $77,900 a year.

2 bedrooms
3 bedrooms

Total monthly housing cost

$1,814/mo

Income to afford it comfortably

$77,900/yr

Income to qualify

$53,460/yr

Your estimated budget

Suggested rent budget, 2 bedrooms

$ —/mo

See what you can afford here

Add your income and debts for a rent budget at this building.

Free with a brightplace account

Fees & lease terms

  • Rent

    $1,485 – $1,950/mo
  • Earliest move-in

    Jan 6

Amenities

The Garratt is pet friendly and has in-unit washers and dryers. It lists 23 amenities, including sparkling resort-style swimming pool, personal patios & balconies, and spacious walk-in closets.

  • Fire Pit & Ping Pong Table

  • Harborfit Fitness Center With Spin Studio

  • Highly Rated Westerville City School District

  • Modern Interiors With Renovated Kitchens, Updated Lighting & Usb-Integrated Outlets

  • Outdoor Kitchen With Gas Grills

  • Outdoor Resident Lounge With Theater

  • Pet-Friendly Community With Dog Park

  • Resident Clubhouse With Wi-Fi & Kitchen Area

  • Spacious Apartment & Townhome Layouts

  • Sparkling Resort-Style Swimming Pool

  • Energy-Efficient Black Appliances

  • Energy-Efficient Windows

  • Full-Size Washer & Dryer Sets

  • Individually Sub-Metered For Electric, Gas And Water

  • Modern Cabinetry With Designer Hardware & Tile Backsplash

  • Modern Kitchen With Sleek Granite Countertops

  • Modern Lighting

  • Personal Patios & Balconies

  • Spacious Walk-In Closets

  • Square Footage Among The Largest In The Market

  • Undermount Sinks With Gooseneck Faucets

  • Usb-Integrated Outlets

  • Wood-Style Flooring


Amenity photos

  • Pool
  • Gym
    2 photos

Location

5415 Turtle Station Way, Westerville, OH, 43081


Resident reviews

The Garratt has a 3.7 out of 5 rating from more than 200 resident reviews. Residents rate location (3.0) and management (2.8) highest and building quality (1.7) lowest.

3.7 · 200+ reviews
Overall rating
Positive
Mixed
Neutral
Negative
Management2.8
Maintenance2.2
Amenities and Shared Spaces2.3
Building Quality1.7
Location3.0
Overall100 reviews

The Garratt experiences a deeply divided resident experience, with roughly equal numbers of positive and negative reviews. Positive residents praise responsive maintenance staff, friendly leasing office personnel, and spacious floor plans, while negative residents report chronic communication failures, prolonged maintenance delays (often 30+ days), pest infestations, high utility costs, and unresolved safety issues. Management responsiveness and service quality appear inconsistent across time periods and individual staff members.

Management responsiveness and maintenance turnaround times are the primary concerns, with residents reporting 30-60+ day waits for repairs and difficulty reaching the office by phone. While some residents praise individual staff members for professionalism and helpfulness, negative reviews consistently cite unresponsive communication, incomplete repairs, and slow issue resolution since recent management transitions. Billing practices and additional fees also generate frustration, though positive experiences highlight staff availability and problem-solving when residents can connect with management.

Maintenance response times are severely delayed, with work orders frequently taking 30-60+ days to address or remaining unresolved for months. Common issues include HVAC failures during extreme temperatures, appliance malfunctions (washers, dryers, dishwashers), plumbing leaks, and pest infestations that persist despite multiple reports. Communication from maintenance and management is inconsistent, with residents reporting difficulty reaching staff, unanswered emails, and work orders marked complete without actual repairs being performed.

Amenities at this property include a gym and pool that residents appreciate, but shared spaces and services have significant issues. Trash collection is frequently unreliable despite paid valet service, with missed pickups and overflow in common areas. Maintenance response times are extremely slow (30-60+ days reported), and parking enforcement has become problematic with new towing policies and inconsistent guest parking. Utility costs are notably high with undisclosed community fees.

Residents report significant building quality concerns including persistent maintenance delays (often 30+ days or longer), unresolved structural issues like water damage and leaks, pest infestations, and poor cleanliness throughout common areas. Multiple reviews cite code violations identified by city inspectors, inadequate HVAC systems, poor insulation, and deteriorating finishes. One positive review praised cleanliness and maintenance responsiveness, but this represents a stark minority among the selected reviews.

The location offers convenient access to nearby shopping and dining options, with several residents highlighting proximity to retail and restaurants. However, the area experiences significant traffic congestion from ongoing construction, and the surrounding neighborhood has shown signs of decline. Parking enforcement and towing practices have been inconsistent, creating frustration for residents.

Summaries are written by AI from reviews residents posted on public review sites. Each topic shows how many of those reviews discuss it.

Getting around

The Garratt is car-dependent and not bikeable, and transit is minimal.

Walking
Car-dependent
Grade F
Transit
Minimal
Grade F
Biking
Not bikeable
Grade F

About this property

The Garratt | Spacious 2-bedroom apartments in Little Turtle, Westerville, OH with fantastic amenities and a prime location near Lower Lights Cooper Road.


Nearby schools

The closest school to The Garratt is Sunbury KinderCare, a private preschool 0.8 miles away. The closest public school is Huber Ridge Elementary School, 1.6 miles away.

SchoolTypeLevelDistance

Sunbury KinderCare

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.8 mi

Ywca Sch/Age Pgrm-Wilder

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.8 mi

Huber Ridge Elementary School

Public · Elementary
PublicElementary1.6 mi

Montessori Beginnings Pre-K

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool1.6 mi

Kinder Care Learning Center #83

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool1.8 mi

Early Learning

Public · Preschool
PublicPreschool1.9 mi

Pointview Elementary School

Public · Elementary
PublicElementary1.9 mi

Cherrington Elementary School

Public · Elementary
PublicElementary2.3 mi

Vineyard Early Child Care Center

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool2.4 mi

Ywca Sch/Age Pgrm-Mark Twain

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool2.5 mi

Similar properties

The closest matches in Westerville, OH.


Rent history

Over the past year, the average asking rent at The Garratt has ranged from $1,662 to $2,206. The current average is $1,662, the lowest in the past year.

Prices reflect the average advertised rent across units listed as available each day (156 days observed).

How fast apartments rent

Apartments at The Garratt typically stay listed about 13 days before coming off the market. In the last 4 weeks, 1 came off the market and 25 were newly listed.

~13 days

typical time listed

1

came off the market in 4 weeks

25

new listings in 4 weeks

Week of Aug 31: 8 listed, 7 off the marketWeek of Sep 7: 6 listed, 7 off the marketWeek of Sep 14: 1 listed, 3 off the marketWeek of Sep 21: 8 listed, 9 off the marketWeek of Sep 28: 5 listed, 9 off the marketWeek of Oct 5: 9 listed, 10 off the marketWeek of Oct 12: 3 listed, 22 off the marketWeek of Oct 19: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Oct 26: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Nov 2: 0 listed, 0 off the marketWeek of Nov 9: 24 listed, 1 off the marketWeek of Nov 16: 1 listed, 0 off the marketAug 31Week of Nov 16
Newly listed
Came off the market

Apartments here go quickly. If one fits, it's worth touring soon.

From nightly checks of the building's website since May 7. An apartment that came off the market may have rented or been taken off by the building.

Contact & management

The Garratt is managed by Harbor Group International. The leasing office's phone number is +13802287898.