How can I help?

brightplace uses ai, verify answers

Unit 443 at The Nicholas

$1,634/mo

Available December 7

1 bed · 1 bath · 774 sq ft

12 W Gay St, Unit 443, Columbus, OH 43215
See all units at The Nicholas

As of November 19, 2026, Unit 443 at The Nicholas in Columbus, OH is a 1-bed, 1-bath, 774 sq ft apartment renting for $1,634 a month, available December 7. It is one of 12 available 1-bed units here, which rent for $1,488 to $2,002. Listed since November 3.


Unit details

Unit 443 at The Nicholas has the A6-0 floor plan. Garage or covered parking is available and the unit has an in-unit washer and dryer.

  • Unit

    #443
  • Floor plan

    A6-0
  • Beds

    1 bd
  • Baths

    1 ba
  • Size

    774 sqft
  • Parking

    Garage or covered parking
  • Laundry

    In-unit washer and dryer

Fees & lease terms

  • Rent

    $1,634/mo
  • Earliest move-in

    Dec 7

Cost to rent this unit

Unit 443 at The Nicholas costs about $1,893 a month all-in: $1,634 rent and an estimated $259 for electric, gas, water, internet, and renters insurance.

All-in$1,893/mo

Estimates are local averages, not quotes from the property.

Building amenities

The Nicholas has garage or covered parking and in-unit washers and dryers. It lists 51 building amenities, including personal terrace or balcony*, dishwasher, and business center 1 of 1.

  • 24/7 Controlled Building Access

  • 24/7 Emergency Maintenance

  • 24/7 Emergency Service Team

  • 24/7 Fitness Center With State-Of-The-Art Matrix Cardio & Weight Training Equipment*

  • 2-Inch Nuwood Blinds

  • An Edwards Urban Community

  • Artisan Inserted Panel Doors With Brushed Nickel Hardware

  • Bark Park 1 Of 1

  • Bike Repair Station 1 Of 1

  • Business Center 1 Of 1

  • Ceramic Porcelain Tile Backsplash

  • Clubroom With Billiards Lounge, Fireplace & Entertaining Kitchen 1 Of 2 2 Of 2

  • Contemporary Slab-Front Cabinets In Walnut Or Greybrown 1 Of 1

  • Convenient Internal Trash Chutes

  • Courtyards Featuring Grilling Stations & Fire Pits 1 Of 1

  • Designer Pendant, Track & Under-Mount Lighting

  • Direct Access To Veritas Restaurant And The Citizens Trust Upscale Cocktail Lounge At 11 West Gay*

  • Dishwasher

  • Distinctive Quartz Countertops With Under-Mount Sinks

  • Dramatic Open Living Spaces With 9’ Ceilings 1 Of 1

  • Easy Access I-71, I-670, I-70 & Sr 315

  • Elegant Framed Vanity Mirrors 1 Of 1

  • Energy Star Stainless Steel Kitchen Appliances 1 Of 1

  • Floor To Ceiling Windows With Abundant Natural Light

  • Gooseneck Faucet

  • Interior Mail Room 1 Of 1

  • Lobby Wi-Fi Hotspot With Starbucks Machine

  • Luxer One Monitored Package Room & Locker System With 24/7 Accessibility

  • Management By Award Winning Drucker + Falk

  • Members Clubroom Kitchen 1 Of 1

  • Microwave

  • Minutes From The Arena District, The Short North, German Village, The Brewery District

  • Online Resident Payment System

  • Online Service Requests

  • Open Stainless Shelving Incorporated Into Cabinetry

  • Paw Spa 1 Of 1

  • Personal Terrace Or Balcony*

  • Prewired For Time Warner/Spectrum Television

  • Rainfall Showerheads + Luxurious Soaking Tubs

  • Resident Bike Storage

  • Resident Social Events

  • Rooftop Firepit And Conversation Areas 1 Of 1

  • Rooftop Pool With Grilling, Dining And Lounge Areas 1 Of 1

  • Sleek Glass Top Range

  • Spacious Kitchen Islands, Breakfast Bars & Pantries*

  • Stunning City Views

  • Under-Building Parking Garage With Direct Building Access Available

  • Washer And Dryer Included For Free 1 Of 1

  • White Glazed Elongated Subway Tile Tub & Shower Surrounds

  • Wide Plank Wood Finish Flooring In Living Area & Bath

  • Yoga Studio


Other 1-bed units available here

  • Unit 205

    $1,488/mo · 1 bed · 1 bath · 755 sq ft

  • Unit 510

    $1,634/mo · 1 bed · 1 bath · 680 sq ft

  • Unit 554

    $1,634/mo · 1 bed · 1 bath · 680 sq ft

  • Unit 352

    $1,637/mo · 1 bed · 1 bath · 690 sq ft

  • Unit 541

    $1,644/mo · 1 bed · 1 bath · 774 sq ft

  • Unit 421

    $1,653/mo · 1 bed · 1 bath · 677 sq ft


Location

12 W Gay St, Columbus, OH, 43215


Resident reviews

The Nicholas has a 4.7 out of 5 rating from more than 100 resident reviews. Residents rate location (4.9) and amenities and shared spaces (4.6) highest and maintenance (3.8) lowest.

4.7 · 100+ reviews
Overall rating
Positive
Mixed
Neutral
Negative
Location4.9
Amenities and Shared Spaces4.6
Management4.4
Building Quality4.0
Maintenance3.8
Overall97 reviews

The Nicholas offers a prime downtown location with excellent amenities including a pool, gym, and multiple courtyards, attracting residents who value walkability to restaurants and entertainment. Staff responsiveness and maintenance quality are frequently praised, though recent reviews indicate communication challenges in the leasing office and concerns about common area maintenance and package security. The property maintains strong appeal for those prioritizing location and amenities, but prospective residents should be aware of ongoing operational inconsistencies.

The Nicholas offers an exceptional downtown location within walking distance of restaurants, shops, entertainment venues, and the Scioto River, making it ideal for those seeking urban convenience without requiring a car. The secure, gated parking garage and key fob building access provide reliable parking and safety. Residents consistently praise the walkability to major attractions including the Short North, Arena District, and riverfront, along with abundant nearby dining and retail options. One review noted street noise from the active High Street corner and construction activity, though this appears isolated among the overwhelmingly positive location feedback.

The Nicholas offers extensive amenities including a well-maintained infinity pool, fitness center, yoga studio, and multiple courtyards that residents consistently praise. Secure parking, dog wash facilities, and bike storage are available. However, recent reviews indicate concerns about package management, common area cleanliness, and office communication responsiveness, suggesting a decline in operational consistency.

Management responsiveness and communication have declined significantly in recent years, with residents reporting delayed responses to emails, unresolved maintenance requests, and poor coordination during the leasing process. However, positive reviews highlight that when staff are engaged, they are helpful and professional, and maintenance teams remain consistently responsive. Current challenges include high office staff turnover, package management issues, and inconsistent follow-up on resident concerns, though the property's location and amenities continue to be valued.

The Nicholas offers a well-maintained modern building with strong amenities, responsive maintenance, and a prime downtown location. Common areas and unit finishes are generally clean and well-kept, though some residents report occasional cleanliness issues in shared spaces and noise from street activity. Recent management transitions have created communication gaps and operational inconsistencies that contrast with the building's physical quality.

Maintenance response is generally prompt and effective, with staff noted as responsive to work orders and repairs. However, recent reviews indicate broader operational challenges including staff turnover, communication gaps, and inconsistent upkeep of common areas and amenities. The property shows mixed performance: some residents report quick maintenance service, while others cite recurring issues with facility maintenance and management responsiveness.

Summaries are written by AI from reviews residents posted on public review sites. Each topic shows how many of those reviews discuss it.

Getting around

The Nicholas is very walkable and very bikeable, and transit is good.

Walking
Very walkable
Grade B
Transit
Good
Grade C
Biking
Very bikeable
Grade B

About this property

We are open and ready to help you find your new home! Call or Text us today! An Edwards Urban Community


Nearby schools

The closest school to The Nicholas is Children First Child Care Center, a private preschool 0.2 miles away.

SchoolTypeLevelDistance

Children First Child Care Center

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.2 mi

Ywca Kidscape-Jefferson

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.3 mi

Ywca Mark Twain Child Care Program

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.3 mi

Ywca Child Care Pgrm-Wilder

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.3 mi

City Kids Inc Dc Downtown

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.3 mi

Early College Academy

Charter · High
CharterHigh0.3 mi

Primrose School of Columbus Downtown

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.4 mi

C James Grotaus Child Care Center

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.5 mi

Cdc Kae Head Start

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.5 mi

Fouse Ywca School-Age Child Care Center

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.5 mi

Contact & management

The Nicholas is managed by Drucker & Falk. The leasing office's phone number is (380) 324-7511.