How can I help?
$1,733/mo
Available now
2 beds · 2 baths · 1,055 sq ft
152 E New York St, Unit 518, Indianapolis, IN 46204See all units at Pulliam SquareAs of November 21, 2026, Unit 518 at Pulliam Square in Indianapolis, IN is a 2-bed, 2-bath, 1,055 sq ft apartment renting for $1,733 a month, available now. It is one of 7 available 2-bed units here, which rent for $1,714 to $2,057. Listed since November 19.
Unit 518 at Pulliam Square has the Register floor plan. Pets are allowed, garage or covered parking is available, and the unit has an in-unit washer and dryer.
Unit
518Floor plan
RegisterBeds
2 bdBaths
2 baSize
1,055 sqftPets
Pets allowedParking
Garage or covered parkingLaundry
In-unit washer and dryerRent
$1,733/moEarliest move-in
Nov 21Unit 518 at Pulliam Square costs about $2,022 a month all-in: $1,733 rent and an estimated $289 for electric, gas, water, internet, and renters insurance.
All-in$2,022/mo
Unit 518 at Pulliam Square lists 6 amenities, including in-unit washer and dryer.
Granite Countertops
In-Unit Washer And Dryer
Modern Upscale Finishes
Pet-Friendly
Stainless Steel Appliances
Wood-Style Plank Flooring
Pulliam Square is pet friendly and has garage or covered parking. It lists 11 building amenities, including fitness center, resident lounge with pool table, and free bike storage.
Award-Winning Management
Bocce Ball Court
Complimentary Coffee Bar
Connected Parking Garage
Courtyard With Firepit And City Views
Electric Car Charging Stations
Fitness Center
Free Bike Storage
On-Site Maintenance
Resident Lounge With Pool Table
Shared Dog Park
152 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN, 46204
Pulliam Square has a 4.4 out of 5 rating from more than 100 resident reviews. Residents rate location (4.9) and maintenance (4.5) highest and building quality (2.9) lowest.
Pulliam Square offers a prime downtown location with spacious, modern apartments and responsive maintenance service. The property is consistently praised for its friendly, professional staff and community-oriented management. However, some residents report recurring issues with fire alarms, noise from adjacent bars on weekend nights, and occasional delays in administrative processes like refunds and service requests.
Management and office staff are consistently praised for professionalism, responsiveness, and genuine care for residents, with many noting their willingness to work with tenants and organize community events. However, some residents report challenges with office hours availability, package handling procedures, and responsiveness to maintenance requests, particularly during staff transitions. Communication about building issues like fire alarms and maintenance delays has been inconsistent, though most recent reviews highlight improved responsiveness.
Pulliam Square offers an exceptional downtown location with walkable access to Mass Avenue restaurants, shops, and entertainment, plus convenient parking and proximity to regional transit. Residents consistently praise the prime central location as unbeatable for downtown living, with easy access to nearby amenities while maintaining a quiet residential feel inside units. The location's convenience and value for downtown square footage are frequently cited as major highlights, though one review noted occasional maintenance delays on building-wide systems.
Pulliam Square offers well-regarded amenities including a fitness center, business lounge, outdoor patio, and convenient downtown location. Most residents praise responsive and friendly staff and well-maintained common spaces, though some report limited office hours affecting package delivery and service access. A minority of residents noted maintenance concerns including hallway upkeep and occasional fire alarm issues.
Maintenance response times are generally quick, with staff described as professional and responsive to work orders. Most residents report positive experiences with the maintenance team's friendliness and follow-through. However, one resident experienced significant delays in appliance installation and a subsequent installation error that caused water damage, as well as HVAC system failure, indicating occasional gaps in service quality and equipment reliability.
Residents report significant noise issues, particularly from ground-floor venues and construction, with concerns about sound insulation and management responsiveness. Elevator reliability and maintenance communication gaps are recurring problems. However, some residents praise maintenance staff and leasing office support. Building upkeep in common areas, including hallway finishes and fire alarm system reliability, present ongoing concerns.
Pulliam Square is very walkable and very bikeable, and transit is limited.
View pricing and availability for studio, one, and two bedroom apartments at Pulliam Square Indianapolis, and find your next downtown home today.
The closest school to Pulliam Square is Shalom Day Care, a private preschool 0.1 miles away. The closest public school is Arlington Community Middle School, 0.4 miles away.
| School | Type | Level | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|
Shalom Day Care Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 0.1 mi |
The American Academy Private · High | Private | High | 0.3 mi |
Day Nursery Fed Center Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 0.3 mi |
Day Nursery-State Center Dc Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 0.3 mi |
K12 International Academy Private · High | Private | High | 0.3 mi |
Day Nursery Assn Indpls Lilly Br Private · Elementary | Private | Elementary | 0.4 mi |
Day Nursery Assn Indpls Wiles Br Private · Elementary | Private | Elementary | 0.4 mi |
Day Nursery State Center Private · Elementary | Private | Elementary | 0.4 mi |
Arlington Community Middle School Public · Middle | Public | Middle | 0.4 mi |
Fuzzie Bear Child Care Center Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 0.6 mi |
Pulliam Square is managed by Coastal Ridge Real Estate. The leasing office's phone number is (317)-686-9913.