The Winchester
1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • 663 Sq Ft
Starting at $945/mo
How can I help?

$945 – $1,225/mo
As of November 22, 2026, Williamsburg Way in Columbus, IN has 15 apartments for rent from $945 to $1,225/mo. One-bedrooms start at $945, two-bedrooms at $975, and three-bedrooms at $1,225. The average asking rent has fallen 6.9% since April 10, 2026, from $1,120 to $1,043.
Prices lately
1.8% lower
Listed apartments, last 30 daysPrice vs. nearby
14% above
Similar apartments, by size15 apartments available
1 bd 3 · 2 bd 11 · 3 bd 1
3 ready to move in now
More open up from Nov 25
Rents in about 5 days
Typical time an apartment stays listed
Williamsburg Way has 15 units available across 3 floor plans: a one-bedroom layout (663 sq ft), a two-bedroom layout (885 sq ft), and a three-bedroom layout (1,216 sq ft). Prices checked November 22, 2026.
1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • 663 Sq Ft
Starting at $945/mo
2 Bedrooms • 1 Bath • 885 Sq Ft
Starting at $975/mo
| 11 available units | Price | Price while listed | Sq ft | Available | Actions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17E | $1,035 No change | No change | 885 | Oct 7 | |
| 03C | $975 −$60 | −$60 | 885 | Oct 24 | |
| 22D | $1,035 No change | No change | 885 | Nov 25 | |
| 26C | $1,035 No change | No change | 885 | Nov 25 | |
| 04A | $1,035 No change | No change | 885 | Nov 30 | |
| 16C | $1,035 No change | No change | 885 | Nov 30 | |
| 19A | $1,035 No change | No change | 885 | Nov 30 | |
| 10F | $1,035 No change | No change | 885 | Dec 11 | |
| 21A | $1,080 No change | No change | 885 | Dec 16 | |
| 04D | $1,035 No change | No change | 885 | Jan 8 | |
| 28C | $1,035 No change | No change | 885 | Feb 5 | |
At Williamsburg Way, a one-bedroom starts at about $1,175 a month all-in: $945 rent and an estimated $230 for electric, gas, water, internet, and renters insurance. A two-bedroom starts at about $1,272 and a three-bedroom at about $1,611.
All-in from$1,175/mo
Most property managers ask for a monthly income of about 3× the rent, so qualifying at Williamsburg Way takes about $34,020 a year for a one-bedroom, $35,100 for a two-bedroom, and $44,100 for a three-bedroom. Keeping the $1,175 all-in month for a one-bedroom within 35% of take-home pay takes an income of about $49,300 a year.
Total monthly housing cost
$1,175/mo
Income to afford it comfortably
$49,300/yr
Income to qualify
$34,020/yr
$ —/mo
See what you can afford here
Add your income and debts for a rent budget at this building.
Rent
$945 – $1,225/moEarliest move-in
Jan 8Williamsburg Way is pet friendly and has in-unit washers and dryers. It lists 15 amenities, including fitness center, swimming pool, and dishwasher.
24-Hour Emergency Maintenance
Clubhouse
Dog Park
Fitness Center
Flex Rent Payments
Laundry Center
On-Site Management
Playground
Swimming Pool
Central Air
Dishwasher
Spacious Floor Plans
Upgraded Home
Washer/Dryer
Xfinity Services Available
3838 Williamsburg Way, Columbus, IN, 47203
Williamsburg Way apartments show highly polarized resident experiences spanning two decades, with recent reviews predominantly positive and older reviews predominantly negative. Staff responsiveness and maintenance quality appear to be the primary drivers of satisfaction, with newer management showing marked improvement in property condition and service delivery. However, historical concerns about maintenance delays, unit condition issues, and community safety persist in older reviews, suggesting significant operational changes have occurred over time.
Management and office staff receive consistent praise for friendliness, responsiveness, and helpfulness across multiple reviews. Staff typically address maintenance requests promptly, often same-day or next-day service. However, some residents report inconsistent follow-through on repairs and occasional communication gaps, with experiences varying by management tenure and staffing changes.
Maintenance experiences at this property vary significantly across review periods. Recent positive reviews highlight responsive same-day or next-day service and courteous staff, while older reviews document extended delays, incomplete repairs, and communication gaps. The property has undergone management and maintenance team changes, with some residents reporting marked improvements in service responsiveness and work quality, though concerns about follow-through on complex repairs persist.
Residents report significant building maintenance and condition issues, including persistent leaks in plumbing fixtures, windows, and ceilings that often go unrepaired for extended periods. Noise insulation is poor, with residents able to hear neighbors' conversations, televisions, and activities through thin walls and doors. Common complaints include dirty common areas, malfunctioning appliances, and slow or incomplete maintenance responses, though some residents note that staff can be responsive when issues are escalated.
Residents consistently praise the property's cleanliness, well-maintained amenities, and responsive staff. The community features a pool, gym, clubhouse, on-site laundry facilities, and ample parking. Common themes include a quiet, friendly neighborhood atmosphere and convenient access to nearby shopping and services.
Residents consistently praise the property's convenient in-town location with proximity to shops and services, as well as access to public transit. The neighborhood is noted as quiet and friendly with responsive staff. Parking areas are available, though one review mentioned potholes in the lot.
Williamsburg Way is somewhat walkable and not bikeable.
Williamsburg Way is a 192-unit building in Columbus, IN.
Building
ApartmentTotal units
192The closest school to Williamsburg Way is Fairlawn Pre-School, a private preschool 0.3 miles away. The closest public school is L F Smith Elementary, 0.6 miles away.
| School | Type | Level | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|
Fairlawn Pre-School Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 0.3 mi |
L F Smith Elementary Public · Elementary | Public | Elementary | 0.6 mi |
Little Lambs Child Care Center Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 0.7 mi |
Clifty Creek Elementary School Public · Elementary | Public | Elementary | 1.3 mi |
Kinder Care Learning Center #300570 Private · Elementary | Private | Elementary | 1.7 mi |
Little Sprouts Bilingual Learning Center Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 2.1 mi |
Wee Little People Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 2.4 mi |
Seed.Sprout.Bloom! Childcare Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 3.3 mi |
Human Services Inc. Birth To Five Center Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 4.4 mi |
Midway Christian Academy Private · High | Private | High | 5.7 mi |
The closest matches in Columbus, IN.
Over the past year, the average asking rent at Williamsburg Way has ranged from $870 to $1,120. The current average is $1,043, down $77 (6.9%) from $1,120 at the start.
Apartments at Williamsburg Way typically stay listed about 5 days before coming off the market. In the last 4 weeks, 9 came off the market and 21 were newly listed.
~5 days
typical time listed
9
came off the market in 4 weeks
21
new listings in 4 weeks
Apartments here go quickly. If one fits, it's worth touring soon.
From nightly checks of the building's website since Apr 10. An apartment that came off the market may have rented or been taken off by the building.Williamsburg Way is managed by MIMG. The leasing office's phone number is 978-540-8457.