How can I help?

No units currently available.
Can you afford it? Rent affordability calculator for Gainesville
The Mill at New Holland has a 4.2 out of 5 rating from more than 100 resident reviews. Residents rate location (4.5) and management (3.8) highest and building quality (2.9) lowest.
The Mill at New Holland offers a convenient location with modern amenities and spacious floor plans that appeal to many residents. Staff responsiveness and friendliness are frequently praised, though experiences vary significantly. Common concerns include ground maintenance issues, pest control challenges, noise from neighbors, and fee structures that some residents find unclear or excessive.
Management responsiveness and professionalism vary significantly across resident experiences. Positive reviews consistently praise office staff friendliness, helpfulness, and responsiveness to maintenance requests, while negative reviews cite slow response times, dismissive attitudes toward resident concerns, and inconsistent policy enforcement. Billing practices and move-out fees are a recurring concern, with some residents reporting unexpected charges and security deposit deductions. Communication frequency and tone have also drawn mixed feedback, with some residents finding management emails excessive or unprofessional.
The property offers well-regarded amenities including a pool, gym, clubhouse, and coffee bar, with spacious floor plans and modern appliances. However, common-area maintenance and ground upkeep have declined over time, with recurring issues including trash management, dog park cleanliness, and debris accumulation. Valet trash service fees and enforcement inconsistencies frustrate residents, while noise from shared spaces and parking violations remain unresolved concerns.
The Mill at New Holland offers a highly convenient location with excellent proximity to restaurants, grocery stores, retail, and the expressway, making it ideal for short commutes and walkable access to dining and shopping. Residents consistently praise the location's central positioning in Gainesville and nearby access to entertainment and services. A small number of residents noted address recognition issues with delivery services and wayfinding challenges due to building signage visibility. Overall, location convenience is a major strength of the property.
Maintenance experiences at this property are highly polarized. Positive reviews highlight responsive and efficient repair service, while negative reviews report significant delays (weeks to months), recurring issues with appliances and structural elements, and unresolved requests. Common concerns include slow response times for work orders, repeated failures to fully resolve plumbing and appliance issues, and pest control challenges.
Residents report significant building quality concerns, particularly persistent pest infestations (roaches, ants) that management has struggled to resolve despite multiple service requests. Noise insulation is inconsistent—upper-floor units report quietness while lower floors near common areas experience substantial noise from gyms and neighboring units. Maintenance response times are slow, with some requests taking weeks or remaining unresolved, and building materials are perceived as lower quality with noticeable vibration and sound transmission between units.
Embrace the comfort you crave and deserve at The Mill at New Holland Apartments! Our community aims to boost your lifestyle through attractive amenity spaces and modern interiors. Our apartments in Gainesville, GA, will win you over with their spacious floor plans and excellent location next to desirable work, dining, shopping, and recreation options.
| School | Type | Level | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|
Joyland Early Learning Center Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | — |
Sandra Dunagan Deal Elementary Public · Elementary | Public | Elementary | — |
First Baptist Day School Dc Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | — |
Riverside Preparatory Academy Private · High | Private | High | — |
New Holland Core Knowledge Academy Public · Elementary | Public | Elementary | — |
First Presbyterian Child Development Center Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | — |
Fair Street International Baccalaureate World School Public · Elementary | Public | Elementary | — |
NE Georgia Medical Day Care Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | — |
Little Learners of Gainesville Private · High | Private | High | — |
Park Street Montessori School Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | — |
The closest matches in Gainesville, GA.
The Mill at New Holland is managed by Fogelman Properties. The leasing office's phone number is (877) 243-8520.