How can I help?

brightplace uses ai, verify answers

Bay Harbor

Bay Harbor – Pool
1 / 7

$1,195 – $1,945/mo

  • 1–3 bedrooms
  • 1–2 baths
  • 530–1,624 sq ft
  • 20 units available
9601 Bay Harbor Cir, Fort Myers, FL, 33919

As of November 22, 2026, Bay Harbor in Fort Myers, FL has 20 apartments for rent from $1,195 to $1,945/mo. One-bedrooms start at $1,195, two-bedrooms at $1,585, and three-bedrooms at $1,735. The average asking rent has fallen 2.1% since June 13, 2026, from $1,558 to $1,525.


At a glance

Prices lately

0.3% lower

Listed apartments, last 30 days

Price vs. nearby

In line

Similar apartments, by size
  • 20 apartments available

    1 bd 9 · 2 bd 7 · 3 bd 4

  • 15 ready to move in now

    More open up from Dec 5

  • Rents in about 2 weeks

    Typical time an apartment stays listed


Floor plans

Bay Harbor has 20 units available across 9 floor plans: 3 one-bedroom layouts (530–1,214 sq ft), 3 two-bedroom layouts (1,105–1,475 sq ft), and 3 three-bedroom layouts (1,291–1,624 sq ft). Prices checked November 22, 2026.

St. Croix with Loft

1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • 1,214 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,460/mo

1 available unitPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailableActions
#20-205$1,460
−$5
−$51,214Dec 28
View Unit
View Unit

St. Lucia

2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,131 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,585/mo

2 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailableActions
#10-201$1,585
+$15
+$151,131Nov 20
View Unit
View Unit
#25-203$1,585
+$50
+$501,131Nov 21
View Unit
View Unit

St. Thomas

2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,105 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,585/mo

4 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailable
#26-101$1,605
+$55
+$551,105Nov 21
#03-104$1,630
+$55
+$551,105Nov 21
#05-104$1,640
Just listed
Just listed1,105Nov 21
#04-104$1,585
+$25
+$251,105Jan 16

St. Lucia with Loft

2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,475 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,625/mo

1 available unitPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailable
#29-201$1,625
+$10
+$101,475Dec 21

St. Kitts

3 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,317 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,735/mo

1 available unitPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailable
#31-201$1,735
−$50
−$501,317Nov 21

St. Kitts with Loft

3 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,624 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,865/mo

2 available unitsPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailable
#18-204$1,895
−$15
−$151,624Nov 21
#37-203$1,865
−$15
−$151,624Dec 17

St. Maarten

3 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,291 Sq Ft

Starting at $1,945/mo

1 available unitPricePrice while listedSq ftAvailable
#31-104$1,945
−$20
−$201,291Nov 21

Estimated cost to rent here

At Bay Harbor, a one-bedroom starts at about $1,422 a month all-in: $1,195 rent and an estimated $227 for electric, gas, water, internet, and renters insurance. A two-bedroom starts at about $1,873 and a three-bedroom at about $2,103.

1 bedroom
2 bedrooms
3 bedrooms

All-in from$1,422/mo

Estimates are local averages, not quotes from the property.

Can you afford it?

Most property managers ask for a monthly income of about 3× the rent, so qualifying at Bay Harbor takes about $43,020 a year for a one-bedroom, $57,060 for a two-bedroom, and $62,460 for a three-bedroom. Keeping the $1,422 all-in month for a one-bedroom within 35% of take-home pay takes an income of about $58,000 a year.

1 bedroom
2 bedrooms
3 bedrooms

Total monthly housing cost

$1,422/mo

Income to afford it comfortably

$58,000/yr

Income to qualify

$43,020/yr

Your estimated budget

Suggested rent budget, 1 bedroom

$ —/mo

See what you can afford here

Add your income and debts for a rent budget at this building.

Free with a brightplace account

Fees & lease terms

  • Rent

    $1,195 – $1,945/mo
  • Earliest move-in

    Jan 16

Amenities

Bay Harbor has garage or covered parking and in-unit washers and dryers. It lists 37 amenities, including 24-hour fitness center, resort-style pool, and dishwasher and garbage disposal.

  • 24-Hour Emergency Maintenance

  • 24-Hour Fitness Center

  • 5 Miles From The Beach

  • Air Conditioning

  • Ceiling Fans

  • Coffee Bar

  • Controlled Access Gates

  • Corner Homes Available

  • Designer Track Lighting

  • Dishwasher And Garbage Disposal

  • Garages Available

  • Gazebo With Lake Views

  • Heat

  • High Speed Internet And Cable Ready

  • Lake And Preserve Views

  • Lake With Lighted Fitness Trail

  • Lofts Available (Or Loft Option)

  • New 2 In Wood Blinds

  • Oak Wood Raised Panel Cabinetry

  • Online Payments Available

  • On-Site Amazon Hub Lockers

  • Outdoor Grilling Area

  • Patios (In Select 1st Floor Apartments)

  • Picnic Areas

  • Private Entrances

  • Professional On-Site Management Team

  • Public Parks Nearby

  • Recycling Area

  • Refrigerator With Ice Maker

  • Resort-Style Pool

  • Smart Home Technology Package

  • Spacious Closets

  • Tile Floors In Entryway, Kitchen, And Bath

  • Two Pet Parks

  • Valet Trash Service

  • Washer And Dryer In Home

  • Wood-Style Plank Flooring Throughout (1st Floor Homes)


Amenity photos

  • Pool
    3 photos
  • Grill area

Location

9601 Bay Harbor Cir, Fort Myers, FL, 33919


Resident reviews

Bay Harbor has a 4.2 out of 5 rating from more than 200 resident reviews. Residents rate location (5.0) and management (4.6) highest and building quality (1.5) lowest.

4.2 · 200+ reviews
Overall rating
Positive
Mixed
Neutral
Negative
Management4.6
Maintenance4.0
Location5.0
Amenities and Shared Spaces2.7
Building Quality1.5
Overall100 reviews

Bay Harbor Apartments delivers a predominantly positive resident experience, with 88% of reviews rating the property favorably. Leasing and office staff receive consistent praise for responsiveness, professionalism, and personalized service throughout the application and move-in process. While the community offers appealing amenities including a pond with walking paths, dog parks, and well-maintained grounds, some residents report maintenance challenges such as aging appliances, AC reliability issues, and pest or mold concerns that require follow-up attention.

Management and office staff receive consistently high praise for responsiveness, professionalism, and genuine care toward residents. The leasing and office teams are noted for clear communication, efficient handling of paperwork, and willingness to assist with issues. However, some residents report billing discrepancies, communication gaps between staff members, and delayed resolution of maintenance requests, suggesting inconsistency in service delivery.

Maintenance responsiveness is generally positive, with staff acknowledged as professional and timely when work orders are submitted. However, recurring issues include aging appliances and building systems (AC, plumbing, dishwashers) that require multiple repair attempts, and some residents report extended resolution timelines. The maintenance team appears understaffed relative to the volume of requests, which can delay non-urgent repairs.

Residents consistently praise Bay Harbor's location for its proximity to stores, shops, and restaurants, creating convenient access to everyday amenities. The neighborhood is noted as safe and quiet with well-maintained common areas including a walking path around the pond. The combination of location convenience, community atmosphere, and responsive staff makes this property an appealing choice for residents prioritizing accessibility and neighborhood character.

Amenities at this property include a pool, gym, gazebo, and a 0.5-mile walking loop around the lake, which residents appreciate. However, shared spaces and amenities experience inconsistent availability—the gym, pool, and leasing office close randomly with limited notice. Maintenance of common areas presents challenges, including persistent trash accumulation near the compactor on weekends and recurring issues with unit-level appliances and systems.

Residents report significant building condition concerns including cracked floors, mold in bathrooms and bedrooms, rusted fixtures, and pest issues requiring multiple exterminator visits. Appliances are described as outdated and frequently malfunctioning, with limited repair responsiveness. Noise transmission between units is noted, and overall maintenance and upkeep appear inconsistent with unit age and pricing.

Summaries are written by AI from reviews residents posted on public review sites. Each topic shows how many of those reviews discuss it.

Getting around

Bay Harbor is car-dependent and not bikeable.

Walking
Car-dependent
Grade F
Biking
Not bikeable
Grade F

About this property

Bay Harbor raises the bar on quality living with remarkable amenities and waterfront 1, 2 & 3 bedroom apartments in Fort Myers, FL. Call us for a tour!


Nearby schools

The closest school to Bay Harbor is Abc Learning Center, a private preschool 0.6 miles away. The closest public school is Cypress Lake High School, 0.9 miles away.

SchoolTypeLevelDistance

Abc Learning Center

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool0.6 mi

Cypress Lake High School

Public · High
PublicHigh0.9 mi

Cypress Lake Middle School

Public · Middle
PublicMiddle0.9 mi

Peace By Piece Learning Center

Private · High
PrivateHigh1.1 mi

Bright Beginnings Early School

Private · Elementary
PrivateElementary1.3 mi

Safe Haven Cc At Cypress Lk Ps

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool1.6 mi

Edison Stay College -Child Care Center

Private · Preschool
PrivatePreschool1.7 mi

Florida SouthWestern Collegiate HS-Lee

Charter · High
CharterHigh1.8 mi

Canterbury School

Private · High
PrivateHigh1.9 mi

Maimonides Hebrew Day School

Private · Elementary
PrivateElementary2.3 mi

Similar properties

The closest matches in Fort Myers, FL.


Rent history

Over the past year, the average asking rent at Bay Harbor has ranged from $1,507 to $1,664. The current average is $1,525, down $33 (2.1%) from $1,558 at the start.

Prices reflect the average advertised rent across units listed as available each day (160 days observed).

How fast apartments rent

Apartments at Bay Harbor typically stay listed about 2 weeks before coming off the market. In the last 4 weeks, 20 came off the market and 16 were newly listed.

~2 weeks

typical time listed

20

came off the market in 4 weeks

16

new listings in 4 weeks

Week of Aug 31: 6 listed, 7 off the marketWeek of Sep 7: 7 listed, 4 off the marketWeek of Sep 14: 6 listed, 6 off the marketWeek of Sep 21: 9 listed, 11 off the marketWeek of Sep 28: 10 listed, 4 off the marketWeek of Oct 5: 3 listed, 1 off the marketWeek of Oct 12: 4 listed, 7 off the marketWeek of Oct 19: 2 listed, 4 off the marketWeek of Oct 26: 5 listed, 7 off the marketWeek of Nov 2: 4 listed, 3 off the marketWeek of Nov 9: 3 listed, 7 off the marketWeek of Nov 16: 4 listed, 2 off the marketAug 31Week of Nov 16
Newly listed
Came off the market

Apartments here go quickly. If one fits, it's worth touring soon.

From nightly checks of the building's website since Jun 13. An apartment that came off the market may have rented or been taken off by the building.

Contact & management

Bay Harbor is managed by Northland. The leasing office's phone number is 239-454-3344.