St. John
Starting at $1,265
1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • 530 Sq Ft
| 5 available units | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #09-205 | $1,265 | 530 | Oct 2 | |
| #32-205 | $1,295 | 530 | Oct 2 | |
| #38-104 | $1,295 | 530 | Oct 2 | |
| #13-202 | $1,295 | 530 | Oct 7 | |
| #13-104 | $1,345 | 530 | Oct 20 |
How can I help?
%20-%20hot%20tub%20removed%20-%20cropped.jpg)
$1,265 – $1,915/mo
9601 Bay Harbor Cir, Fort Myers, FL, 33919Bay Harbor currently lists 9 floor plans across 22 available units, from one-bedroom to three-bedroom, starting at $1,265/mo. 9 one-bedrooms from $1,265 to $1,445/mo (530–1,214 sq ft), earliest move-in Oct 2. 8 two-bedrooms from $1,510 to $1,595/mo (1,105–1,475 sq ft), earliest move-in Oct 2. 5 three-bedrooms from $1,755 to $1,915/mo (1,291–1,624 sq ft), earliest move-in Oct 2. Prices checked October 2, 2026.
Starting at $1,265
1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • 530 Sq Ft
| 5 available units | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #09-205 | $1,265 | 530 | Oct 2 | |
| #32-205 | $1,295 | 530 | Oct 2 | |
| #38-104 | $1,295 | 530 | Oct 2 | |
| #13-202 | $1,295 | 530 | Oct 7 | |
| #13-104 | $1,345 | 530 | Oct 20 |
Starting at $1,445
1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • 1,214 Sq Ft
| 1 available unit | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #19-205 | $1,445 | 1,214 | Oct 2 |
Starting at $1,445
1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • 844 Sq Ft
| 3 available units | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #05-102 | $1,445 | 844 | Oct 8 | |
| #21-101 | $1,445 | 844 | Oct 11 | |
| #33-102 | $1,445 | 844 | Oct 21 |
Starting at $1,510
2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,131 Sq Ft
| 4 available units | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #21-201 | $1,515 | 1,131 | Oct 2 | |
| #04-201 | $1,550 | 1,131 | Oct 2 | |
| #21-202 | $1,550 | 1,131 | Oct 2 | |
| #04-204 | $1,510 | 1,131 | Oct 6 |
Starting at $1,570
2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,105 Sq Ft
| 3 available units | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #26-101 | $1,570 | 1,105 | Oct 2 | |
| #03-104 | $1,595 | 1,105 | Oct 2 | |
| #16-102 | $1,595 | 1,105 | Oct 2 |
Starting at $1,595
2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,475 Sq Ft
| 1 available unit | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #32-204 | $1,595 | 1,475 | Oct 6 |
Starting at $1,755
3 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,317 Sq Ft
| 2 available units | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #31-201 | $1,755 | 1,317 | Oct 2 | |
| #07-202 | $1,785 | 1,317 | Oct 6 |
Starting at $1,890
3 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,624 Sq Ft
| 2 available units | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #18-204 | $1,915 | 1,624 | Oct 2 | |
| #37-203 | $1,890 | 1,624 | Dec 17 |
Starting at $1,900
3 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 1,291 Sq Ft
| 1 available unit | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #14-104 | $1,900 | 1,291 | Oct 2 |
Rent at Bay Harbor is $1,265 – $1,915 per month. The earliest listed move-in is Oct 2. Prices checked October 2, 2026.
Rent
$1,265 – $1,915/moEarliest move-in
Oct 2Bay Harbor lists 37 amenities, including a gym, a pool, and parking.
24-Hour Emergency Maintenance
24-Hour Fitness Center
5 Miles From The Beach
Air Conditioning
Ceiling Fans
Coffee Bar
Controlled Access Gates
Corner Homes Available
Designer Track Lighting
Dishwasher And Garbage Disposal
Garages Available
Gazebo With Lake Views
Heat
High Speed Internet And Cable Ready
Lake And Preserve Views
Lake With Lighted Fitness Trail
Lofts Available (Or Loft Option)
New 2 In Wood Blinds
Oak Wood Raised Panel Cabinetry
Online Payments Available
On-Site Amazon Hub Lockers
Outdoor Grilling Area
Patios (In Select 1st Floor Apartments)
Picnic Areas
Private Entrances
Professional On-Site Management Team
Public Parks Nearby
Recycling Area
Refrigerator With Ice Maker
Resort-Style Pool
Smart Home Technology Package
Spacious Closets
Tile Floors In Entryway, Kitchen, And Bath
Two Pet Parks
Valet Trash Service
Washer And Dryer In Home
Wood-Style Plank Flooring Throughout (1st Floor Homes)
Bay Harbor is at 9601 Bay Harbor Cir, Fort Myers, FL, 33919.
9601 Bay Harbor Cir, Fort Myers, FL, 33919
Residents give Bay Harbor a B grade (about 4.2 out of 5) from 200+ reviews. Bay Harbor Apartments receives overwhelmingly positive feedback, with 89% of reviews rating the experience favorably. Residents consistently praise the leasing office staff for their responsiveness, professionalism, and helpful guidance through the application and move-in process.
Bay Harbor Apartments receives overwhelmingly positive feedback, with 89% of reviews rating the experience favorably. Residents consistently praise the leasing office staff for their responsiveness, professionalism, and helpful guidance through the application and move-in process. The property features attractive amenities including a pond with walking paths, dog parks, and pool areas. However, some residents report ongoing maintenance challenges including aging appliances, mold issues, AC reliability problems, and pest control concerns that require repeated service visits.
Management and office staff receive consistently high praise for responsiveness, professionalism, and genuine care toward residents. The leasing and office teams are noted for clear communication, efficient handling of paperwork, and willingness to assist with ongoing concerns. However, some residents report billing discrepancies, communication gaps between staff members, and delayed resolution of maintenance issues, suggesting inconsistency in service delivery across different interactions.
Maintenance responsiveness is generally positive, with staff acknowledged as professional and attentive to work orders, though response times can be slow due to staffing constraints. Common issues include HVAC failures, plumbing problems, appliance malfunctions (washers, dryers, ovens, refrigerators), and moisture/mold concerns. While many residents report satisfactory resolution of repairs, some experience prolonged issues or incomplete fixes, and unit conditions at move-in occasionally require additional cleaning.
Residents consistently praise Bay Harbor's location for its proximity to stores, shops, and restaurants, creating convenient access to everyday amenities. The neighborhood is noted as safe and quiet with well-maintained common areas including a walking path around the pond. The combination of location convenience, community atmosphere, and responsive staff makes this property an appealing choice for residents prioritizing accessibility and neighborhood character.
Amenities at this property include a pool, gym, gazebo, and a 0.5-mile walking loop around the lake, which residents appreciate. However, shared spaces and amenities experience inconsistent availability, with the gym, pool, and leasing office closing randomly. Maintenance of common areas presents challenges, including persistent trash accumulation near the compactor on weekends and recurring issues with unit-level conditions like mold and moisture that require frequent exterminator visits and maintenance calls.
Residents report significant building condition concerns including cracked floors, mold in bathrooms and bedrooms, rusted fixtures, and pest issues requiring multiple exterminator visits. Appliances are described as outdated and frequently malfunctioning, with limited repair responsiveness. Noise transmission between units and structural concerns such as floor creaking are noted, along with cleanliness issues at move-in and persistent moisture problems requiring ongoing resident intervention.
Bay Harbor is car-dependent and biking is not bikeable.
Car-Dependent
Not Bikeable
Bay Harbor raises the bar on quality living with remarkable amenities and waterfront 1, 2 & 3 bedroom apartments in Fort Myers, FL. Call us for a tour!
Bay Harbor is an apartment.
Building
ApartmentAbc Learning Center is 0.6 miles from Bay Harbor. 10 schools are listed nearby.
| School | Type | Level | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|
Abc Learning Center Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 0.6 mi |
Cypress Lake High School Public · High | Public | High | 0.9 mi |
Cypress Lake Middle School Public · Middle | Public | Middle | 0.9 mi |
Peace By Piece Learning Center Private · High | Private | High | 1.1 mi |
Bright Beginnings Early School Private · Elementary | Private | Elementary | 1.3 mi |
Safe Haven Cc At Cypress Lk Ps Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 1.6 mi |
Edison Stay College -Child Care Center Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 1.7 mi |
Florida SouthWestern Collegiate HS-Lee Charter · High | Charter | High | 1.8 mi |
Canterbury School Private · High | Private | High | 1.9 mi |
Maimonides Hebrew Day School Private · Elementary | Private | Elementary | 2.3 mi |
Bay Harbor is managed by Northland. Call 239-454-3344 to tour or ask about availability.