Commodore Perry Apartments

Commodore Perry offers a prime downtown location with spacious apartments and responsive maintenance service, earning strong praise from most residents. However, persistent infrastructure issues—particularly unreliable elevators and deferred maintenance—along with multiple monthly fees beyond rent, create significant drawbacks that some residents find difficult to overlook.

Commodore Perry's downtown location is its strongest asset, offering walkable access to restaurants, bars, sports venues, and entertainment. Residents consistently praise proximity to Fifth Third Field, Huntington Center, and the farmers market, along with convenient attached parking. However, the historic building presents trade-offs: while spacious floor plans and amenities appeal to many, some residents report concerns with aging infrastructure including unreliable elevators, drafty windows, and thin walls that transmit noise.

Office and leasing staff are consistently praised for professionalism, friendliness, and responsiveness to resident needs. Maintenance requests are typically completed promptly, often same-day or next-day. However, management communication about building-wide issues like elevator outages is inconsistent, and billing practices include numerous additional monthly fees beyond base rent that residents find burdensome.

This historic building offers a desirable downtown location with responsive maintenance and cleaning staff, but residents consistently report significant infrastructure challenges. Elevator reliability is the most persistent issue, with multiple reports of extended outages forcing residents to climb up to 17 flights of stairs. Additional concerns include aging building systems, noise transmission through thin walls, outdated windows and appliances, and deferred maintenance in common areas including stained carpets and uncleaned exterior windows.

Residents appreciate the property's prime downtown location, spacious units, and responsive maintenance staff. However, the building faces persistent challenges with elevator reliability, deferred maintenance in common areas, and numerous monthly fees beyond base rent. Amenities including gym, laundry facilities, and on-site parking are available but require attention to upkeep and accessibility.

Maintenance response times are generally responsive and professional, with staff frequently praised for timely repairs and thorough follow-up. However, the building's aging infrastructure presents persistent challenges, particularly with elevator reliability and HVAC systems. Water damage and plumbing issues have occurred, with some residents reporting delayed response to emergency requests. Overall maintenance quality is strong, but underlying building systems require attention.