Magnolia
3 Bedrooms • 1.5 Baths • 1,160 Sq Ft
Starting at $1,675/mo
| 1 available unit | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5953 5953 | $1,675 | 1,160 | Oct 16 |
How can I help?

$1,675/mo
As of October 13, 2026, McNaughten Plaza in Columbus, OH has 1 apartment for rent at $1,675/mo. The average asking rent has risen 22.3% since May 7, 2026, from $1,370 to $1,675.
1 floor plan · 1 available unit · Prices checked October 13, 2026
3 Bedrooms • 1.5 Baths • 1,160 Sq Ft
Starting at $1,675/mo
| 1 available unit | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5953 5953 | $1,675 | 1,160 | Oct 16 |
See all 22 units listed at McNaughten Plaza, including ones no longer available.
Over the past year, the average asking rent at McNaughten Plaza has ranged from $1,170 to $1,785. The current average is $1,675, up $305 (22.3%) from $1,370 at the start.
| Month | Average asking rent | Lowest – highest | Units listed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 2026 | $1,685 | $1,655 – $1,740 | 1 |
| Sep 2026 | $1,386 | $1,145 – $1,660 | 8 |
| Aug 2026 | $1,432 | $1,150 – $1,615 | 10 |
| Jul 2026 | $1,309 | $1,160 – $1,495 | 9 |
| Jun 2026 | $1,663 | $1,340 – $1,830 | 8 |
| May 2026 | $1,460 | $1,275 – $1,700 | 5 |
Rent
$1,675/moLease term
12 monthsEarliest move-in
Oct 16Pet Rent (Per Pet) | $50/mo |
Renter's Insurance | $18.75/mo |
Trash Removal | $15/mo |
Ulity Billing Administrave Fee | $5/mo |
Administrave Fee | $100 |
Applicaon Fee | $70 |
Insurance Placement Fee | $10 |
Insurance Placement Policy | $15 |
Late Fee | $75 |
Non-Sufficient Funds | $50 |
Pet Fee | $300 |
Security Deposit (Refundable) | $500 |
Vacant Unit Cost Recovery | $50 |
The all-in monthly cost by apartment size, and how the rent compares across the Columbus area.
$2,070/mo
$395/mo above the advertised rent
Rent
$1,675
Pet Rent (Per Pet)
$50
Renter's Insurance
$19
Trash Removal
$15
Ulity Billing Administrave Fee
$5
Electric and gas
$203
Internet
$90
Renters insurance
$13
All-in monthly
$2,070
| Size | Rent from | All-in monthly | Income to qualify |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 bedrooms | $1,675 | $2,070 | $60,300/yr |
Landlords commonly look for a monthly income of three times the rent, about $60,300 a year for the $1,675 three-bedroom. The median renter household in Columbus earns $51,734 a year.
| Size | Median asking rent here | Columbus rent paid |
|---|---|---|
| 3 bedrooms | $1,675 | $1,459 |
Can you afford it? Rent affordability calculator for Columbus
Close To Great Restaurants And Terrific Shopping With Easy Access To Easton, I-270 And Downtown
Extra Storage Available
Fitness Center & Community Clubhouse (Located At Nearby Mcnaughten Woods)
On-Site Parking
Pet-Friendly Community
2 Bedroom Apartments & 2 And 3 Bedroom Townhomes
Accessible Apartment Homes Available
Air Conditioning
Cable/Satellite Ready
Ceiling Fans
Central Heat/Air
Fully Equipped Kitchens
High-Speed Internet Available
Washer & Dryer Connections*
5894 Shana Dr, Columbus, OH, 43232
McNaughten Plaza offers a quiet, clean community environment with strong leasing and move-in support that most residents appreciate. However, maintenance responsiveness and follow-up on work orders present recurring concerns, with some residents reporting significant delays in addressing issues. Management communication and work order handling vary, with positive experiences alongside reports of unresolved maintenance requests and inconsistent office responsiveness.
Management responsiveness is inconsistent, with most residents reporting positive experiences with office and leasing staff who are helpful and responsive to requests. However, some residents report delayed maintenance responses and follow-up issues, particularly with complex or recurring work orders. Long-term residents generally express satisfaction with the property and staff professionalism.
Maintenance response times and follow-through are inconsistent at this property. While some residents report quick service completion and responsive staff, others describe significant delays on work orders—including emergency repairs and health concerns like mold—that went unaddressed for months. Communication and accountability between the office and maintenance team appear to be recurring pain points, though individual staff members have received positive feedback for their professionalism when engaged.
The property offers good value for its location and condition. Residents appreciate the convenient pricing relative to the area and note the property maintains cleanliness and quiet surroundings.
Residents report significant delays in maintenance response, particularly for urgent issues like water damage and mold remediation. Communication from the front office is inconsistent, with requests sometimes taking months to be addressed. While individual maintenance staff members have been noted as helpful, systemic responsiveness issues and incomplete repairs have created frustration among residents.
This resident reports the building is clean and quiet with good overall condition. Staff responsiveness to maintenance requests and move-in issues was noted positively. The property is described as well-maintained for the price and location.
Car-Dependent
Minimal Transit
Not Bikeable
The exceptional lifestyle you've been dreaming of awaits you in Columbus, Ohio. Select from our spacious two- and three-bedroom apartments and townhomes on McNaughten Road, and find the perfect place for your next adventure. Pet-friendly and full of attractive features and amenities, McNaughten Plaza offers everything you need with easy access to the best Columbus, Ohio has to offer. View Fees & Charges Guide For a list of additional fees and charges you may encounter, please view the fees and charges guide. Take note that fees may change at any time and are subject to the terms of the application and lease.
| School | Type | Level | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|
Yorktown Middle School Public · Middle | Public | Middle | 0.4 mi |
Oakmont Elementary School Public · Elementary | Public | Elementary | 0.6 mi |
Kidding Around Day Care & Lc Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 0.6 mi |
Woodcrest Elementary School Public · Elementary | Public | Elementary | 0.8 mi |
Independence High School Public · High | Public | High | 2.0 mi |
Liberty Elementary School Public · Elementary | Public | Elementary | 2.1 mi |
Arts & College Preparatory Academy Charter · High | Charter | High | 2.1 mi |
No Place Like Home Dc-Columbus Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 2.3 mi |
Capital City Career Prep High School Charter · High | Charter | High | 2.6 mi |
Dunloe Elementary School Public · Elementary | Public | Elementary | 2.6 mi |