2x1
Starting at $1,600
2 Bedrooms • 1 Bath • 1,000 Sq Ft
| 1 available unit | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9048-101 | $1,600 | 1,000 | Sep 23 |
How can I help?

$1,600 – $1,675/mo
9035 Starfire Circle, New Haven, IN 46774Gateway currently lists 2 floor plans across 2 available units, from two-bedroom, starting at $1,600/mo. 2 two-bedrooms from $1,600 to $1,675/mo (997–1,000 sq ft), earliest move-in Sep 21. Prices checked September 24, 2026.
Starting at $1,600
2 Bedrooms • 1 Bath • 1,000 Sq Ft
| 1 available unit | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9048-101 | $1,600 | 1,000 | Sep 23 |
Starting at $1,675
2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths • 997 Sq Ft
| 1 available unit | Price | Sq ft | Available | Open unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9147-200 | $1,675 | 997 | Sep 21 |
Rent at Gateway is $1,600 – $1,675 per month. The security deposit is $400. The earliest listed move-in is Sep 21. Prices checked September 24, 2026.
Rent
$1,600 – $1,675/moSecurity deposit
$400Earliest move-in
Sep 21Gateway lists 16 amenities, including a gym, parking, and in-unit laundry.
Ample Parking
Balcony
Central Air
Clubhouse
Country Setting
Dishwasher
Dogs-Some Breeds Restricted
Dryer
Fitness Area
Grilling/Picnic Area
Patio
Refrigerator
Staff On Site
Stove
Trash
Washer
Gateway is at 9035 Starfire Circle, New Haven, IN 46774.
9035 Starfire Circle, New Haven, IN 46774
Residents give Gateway a B+ grade (about 4.4 out of 5) from 33 reviews. Gateway Apartments receives highly polarized reviews reflecting significant changes in management and maintenance over time. Early residents (2025) consistently praised modern, well-maintained units, responsive management, and reasonable pricing.
Gateway Apartments receives highly polarized reviews reflecting significant changes in management and maintenance over time. Early residents (2025) consistently praised modern, well-maintained units, responsive management, and reasonable pricing. However, recent residents (2026) report serious concerns including unresolved mold issues, poor communication, delayed amenity construction, unexpected fee additions, and maintenance responsiveness problems. The property appears to have experienced a notable decline in service quality and issue resolution.
Management experiences vary significantly at this property. Positive reviews consistently praise responsive, friendly, and helpful staff who address resident needs professionally. However, negative reviews report poor communication, unresponsive maintenance, unclear billing practices (unexpected charges for insurance and utilities), and delayed resolution of serious maintenance issues including mold and plumbing problems. Advertised amenities remain incomplete despite resident move-in.
Residents report significant building quality concerns, particularly persistent mold issues on exterior-facing walls that have not been adequately resolved despite multiple maintenance attempts. Communication and responsiveness from management regarding maintenance requests and building conditions have been inconsistent. Advertised amenities remain incomplete, and landscaping upkeep appears limited. Earlier positive reviews do not reflect current conditions under recent management and maintenance changes.
Maintenance responsiveness and follow-through are significant concerns at this property. Residents report difficulty reaching maintenance staff, delayed or incomplete repairs including mold remediation and plumbing issues, and unaddressed maintenance needs. Multiple reviews note a decline in service quality and suggest that maintenance requests are not being prioritized or resolved systematically.
The property offers a desirable location combining country living with convenient access to shopping and amenities nearby. Residents appreciate the balance between a quieter residential setting and proximity to commercial services.
This property advertises amenities that have not been constructed, yet residents are charged full rent. Common maintenance issues include mold and condensation problems that receive only temporary fixes rather than permanent solutions. Landscaping upkeep is minimal, and management communication regarding repairs and amenity timelines has been inconsistent.
Gateway is car-dependent (grade F) and biking is not bikeable (grade F).
F
Car-Dependent
F
Not Bikeable
Gateway Apartments Welcome to the brand new Gateway Apartments. Make Gateway your new luxury home.
Gateway Apartments Welcome to the brand new Gateway Apartments. Make Gateway your new luxury home. Located 3 minutes to downtown New Haven, 5 minutes from I469, and 12 minutes from downtown Fort Wayne. A walking path located on our path can make activity easy with biking available to downtown New Haven and to many restaurants and shops off of Maysville Road. We would love to have you apart of our beautiful brand new community.
Gateway is an apartment.
Building
ApartmentSt Louis Academy is 1.1 miles from Gateway. 10 schools are listed nearby.
| School | Type | Level | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|
St Louis Academy Private · Middle | Private | Middle | 1.1 mi |
New Haven Primary School Public · Elementary | Public | Elementary | 2.5 mi |
Central Lutheran School Private · Middle | Private | Middle | 2.5 mi |
Central Lutheran School Private · Middle | Private | Middle | 2.6 mi |
New Haven High School Public · High | Public | High | 2.7 mi |
New Haven Middle School Public · Middle | Public | Middle | 2.9 mi |
St John The Baptist School Private · Middle | Private | Middle | 3.0 mi |
Martini Kid's Club Ministry Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 3.5 mi |
New Haven Intermediate School Public · Elementary | Public | Elementary | 3.8 mi |
Westridge Amish School Private · Preschool | Private | Preschool | 3.8 mi |
Gateway is managed by ShowMeTheRent.com. Call (260) 305-2416x7 to tour or ask about availability.